I read a book recently, called
Bend, Not Break: A Life in Two Worlds
by Ping Fu.
I came across this book due to pure coincidence or more appropriately described a mistake a few months ago. At that time, I read a free book/document really popular among PhD students in US and China –The PhD Grind by Philip Guo (written by a PhD graduate from Stanford, majored in Computer Science), which, by the way, is a great book. After read that book, I went the website of the author (Philip Guo) and Ping Fu’s book somehow appeared on that website, so I mistook her book as another book that Guo has written. Now I realized that it might be some random advertisement just happened to be there. Anyway, that’s why I brought this book – bend, not break. I only started to read it a few days ago without any knowledge of what this book is about. Now move on to the book.
I was really impressed by the author’s life story and her ability to tell a story. I was instantly absorbed to the story. The story goes like this : A girl grew up in a wealthy family until the outbreak of China’s Cultural Revolution. She was separated by Red Guards from her family, and then had to take care of her little sister at age of eight. During that time, she went through extensive torture and abuse (including be gang-raped at age of ten) . Then at age of 25, she was deported by Chinese government and came to US and began her legendary life experience from being a waitress to a CEO of a company specialized in 3D printing. Despite the hardship she had to go through over those years, she always remembered to be like bamboo, bend but not break, to be like a pine tree, strong and be like plum blossom-courageous. On top of that, she treated people who had humiliated her with forgiveness and kind. And many more. How could you not be impressed by this girl, now a successful CEO in US? If only her story was true.
Her story only appeared to be true to me because I am too young to experience the Cultural revolution first hand myself. I don’t know much about it, and I have heard much about it either although both of my parents have been thourgh that period of time. My father got sent to the country side for labor for a while and his brother faked disability in order to stay at home. Over those years, I have heard nothing about what really happened during that period. I knew it was dark-teachers and professors were prosecuted by their teenager students. However, even as naive as I, I found her story suspicious, starting from the very beginning of the book that she got deported to America because of some article she wrote in 1980s. For one thing, if someone pissed his or her government off, the last thing authorities would do is sending her or him off to another country. What do they try to accomplish by doing that? If she said she was escaped to America since she couldn’t stand the torture, I might have believed her story. Not until the end of the book, I learned what she meant by being deported or exiled by Chinese government — an authority called her and asked her to leave the country and never come back —- after she already asked her father’s student who studied in US to secure her a position as ESL student at University of New Mexico. When I was reading this sentence, I was like ” Seriously? You could have done a better job lying.” For one thing, since when Chinese government start to just call people on the phone instead of just coming at your doorstep and locking you up ?
Ping Fu must think all people in this country are too gullible to spot her lies, or she is counting on labeling all critics as people working for Chinese government and/or who got brainwashed by Chinese government (apparently that has already happened), so she can cater to her American boss and get them to believe her outrageous lies? That reminded me something I have read before, “you don’t have to be logical and providing evidence to back up your statement when you are in a disagreement with others ,only thing that you need to do is questioning other party’s motive. As soon as you labeled them as being brainwashed, you win. ” In this particular case, despite piling evidence against her words and her self-contradicting stories over these year, some people still stand up for her and smear anyone who questioned her book as “Chinese nationals” and “Communists”. I have to agree her plan is a solid one because it is impossible to lose an argument that way. When I first got to this country, my landlord who is an American woman in her 40s, asked me if it is true that I cannot get married in US since Chinese government won’t allow me to. Now I can see where those misunderstandings are coming from (more than one outrageous liars).
There are many inconsistencies in her story that some reviewers have reviewed extensively on Amazon so I will not repeat. One of the longest is http://tiny.cc/6jkw1w .Since it is too long, the author had to published somewhere else.
Things I remember in her book was when she arrived at US, she was penniless. She didn’t even have five extra dollars to pay the fee at the airport. I was like “you have the money to buy an airplane ticket from China to US, but you don’t have five dollars in your pocket the second you got off that plane? Seriously insulting people’s intelligence. At that time, I thought maybe she get deported by Chinese government, so the government brought her the ticket. Now I know that is not the case, it was her own choices (she admitted that she wasn’t expelled by Chinese in an interview). Then how exactly did she get here? You can just tell Americans (Visa officers) that your country asked you to leave, they will just give you the visa to come to US even when you have absolutely no money at all? Even today, financial statements and proof of income of your family if they are the one supporting you (pay for tuition, living expense and etc) are required to apply for a visa to come to US. If her penniless story was true, then she must have faked her financial statements when she applied for the visa which is breaking the law. Why US government does not deport her back to China then? (Btw, US citizenship and immigration services award this lair outstanding American by choice in 2012 based on her lies . I am wondering how they feel about it now.) Awarding one of the biggest liar when it comes to obtain legal status in US.Even at the end of the book, she mentioned this award, she wrote things like “I did not come to US by choice and I had to come). She later admitted that she came here willingly, not being deported as she described in the book and then admitted that some stories in her book are her imagination. Oh? Autobiography is about people telling life stories only happened in one’s head.
She then mentioned in the book that after five years (in 1989) she was in US, she didn’t have any personal life and cannot fit in. However, she was married at Sept, 1986 to an American citizen according to her interview and only got divorced three years later. So she thought getting married was work (since she claimed to have NO personal life) and married an American seemed did nothing for her in terms of “fitting in”. Even worse, she didn’t mention a word about her first husband in the entire book and went at length to hide it and made her first few years at America seems like a person who lived totally on her own. When questioned why she didn’t mention her first marriage, she said it was to protect the identity of that guy. Interesting, like people cannot look your up online. Marriage is public record. She apparently doesn’t remember when she graduated from college and what she did between her graduation and her deportation to US. When people asked her about that during an interview, she said” this is a good question, I have to verify for that” For what? I will remember that period of my time forever. If anyone has asked me the gap between my college graduation and the day I came to US, I will give a detailed account of those events to the exact date without the need to verifying anything. Only reason she has to verify “back home” is that if what she said of her past were all outrageous lies since people tend to forget about details of their lies. If one cannot remember things happened in one’s twenties, how she can remember what happened in her childhood (active imagination then). She also claimed to know only three English phrases at the time she arrived US while all college students were required to learn English for four years. The genius Ping who didn’t even know what dose ” take a break” mean after years of English class she had to take in College, but somehow managed to get both a master degree and a bachelor degree in Computer sciences and found a job only five years after she arrived US (she studied literature in China). Is she a genius in all others things but the language? She mentioned in the book, she didn’t even know about fractions when she first took the calculus class in US, but if that is true, how can she get into college back in China through taking one of the most competitive national college entrance exam in China’s history including subjects like math/chemistry/physics). How gullible she thought her readers are?
I will continue no more. The only reason why I wrote this at the middle of the night is partially due to my frustration towards this book itself (I spent hours reading it and only find out it is a book full of lies) and partially because the questioning her book started back in Jan and I didn’t know about it until I almost finished this book. If I knew about this, I would save myself some time. I feel bad I even considered recommending this book to my friends when I first started reading it. I should have known what I can get from reading an autobiography written by a business woman who majored in literature ( an excellent combination for people who are good at making stuff up). This would serve as a reminder to myself that I should avoid such a book in the future, seriously, what I am thinking.
I know most Chinese and Chinese immigrants out there will not believe what she has said in that book, since those lies are just to easy to spot for people has lived in China before. You don’t even have to like Chinese government at all to call her a liar. So just save you guys sometime, If you ever read that book, you can read it as a pure fiction (you will learn a point or two from it). However, I hope how to learn how to lie shameless will not be a part of it. For others who know nothing about China, or only things that your government has told you through those years, this would be an excellent book for you to read, since it would fit your idea of China perfectly. I am not bothered about the image of Chinese government since in my opinion, its image cannot be worse. If you simply want to learn something about China, I cannot think of any book can be worse than this one for you to start. What this woman tried to do is just promoting herself and her company by making up stories. Spend your 27 dollars elsewhere.